Hundreds of thousands have fled to other countries in Southeast Asia, including Malaysia, Indonesia, and Philippines. However, in recent times, as the Rohingya situation becomes more protracted, Bangladesh is starting to face internal tensions as prospects for repatriation become less likely. Since then, the Rohingya people have been persecuted on a regular basis by the government and nationalist Buddhists. The Rohingya have fled Myanmar after a military crackdown which began three years ago in which UN investigators say as many as 10,000 people were killed and more than 730,000 forcibly displaced. Rohingya settlements on the left, and Bangladeshi ones on the right. The UN said it has not been involved in the process while rights organisations say the government used “cash incentives” as well as “intimidation tactics” to force Rohingya to accept the relocation offer. Housing blocks have been set up for the new arrivals on the island that Foreign Minister AK Abdul Momen has called a “beautiful resort”. Spain returns people who swam from Morocco, adds troops to border, Al Jazeera Centre for Public Liberties & Human Rights. Now, weeks of preparation will be put to the test as aid responders dive into uncharted territory: containing and treating a pandemic in a refugee camp. Bangladesh has provided refuge to generations of ethnic Rohingya who fled previous waves of persecution in Myanmar but has never allowed Rohingya children to access to formal, accredited education. An estimated 12,000 reached Bangladesh during the first half of 2018. My ongoing research indicates that many factors played a critical role in Bangladesh’s political decision to host the Rohingya, including the country’s cultural and religious identity, which centers around ideas of community and responding to those in need. People move across these borders for agricultural purposes. Second group of 1,800 Rohingya refugees sent to Bhasan Char island amid concerns many of them have been coerced. The tensions between the various religious groups in the country were often exploited by past military rulers of Myanmar. In 2020, Bangladesh began building barbed-wire fencing and installing watchtowers around the camps, citing security concerns. The Conversation UK receives funding from these organisations. As Bangladesh grapples with the pandemic while serving as one of the world’s largest refugee host countries, it serves as a reminder of the disproportionate responsibility carried by low-income countries of hosting refugees and the challenges therein. Religious leaders also used these concepts to encourage donations. But rights activists expressed new doubts about the transfers, saying some Rohingya had found their shanty homes in the camps padlocked so they had no choice but to go. Where are Rohingya refugees? Since 2017, more than 730,000 Rohingya have crossed into Bangladesh, fleeing a vicious military campaign of killing, rape and arson in Buddhist-majority Myanmar, which saw them as foreign interlopers. Rohingya in Bangladesh resist repatriation attempt Rohingyas report fleeing killings, destruction and rape. The psychology of pandemics How could we even think of turning them away?”. More than 740,000 Rohingya Muslims live in Bangladesh after fleeing Myanmar's military crackdowns. The crisis had literally arrived at our house. Following a 2017 crackdown on Rohingya Muslims in Myanmar, many fled across the border to Bangladesh. Since 2017, Bangladesh has submitted three proposals at the United Nations General Assembly to address the Rohingya crisis, including in 2019, drawing support from Rohingya activists. Why shouldn’t we? Navy Commodore Abdullah Al Mamun Chowdhury said at least 1,804 Rohingya were being moved in ships to Bhasan Char. It took barely an hour to move [about] 1,800 Rohingya refugees in several navy vessels to head towards Bhasan Char, which is 42km from Chittagong [Chattogram], he said. As many as half of the Rohingya refugees in Bangladesh are not properly nourished, according to WHO. Nearly 80% of Rohingya refugees are women and children. However, not all those who were interviewed invoked religion to explain their actions. More than 740,000 Rohingya are in camps in Bangladesh after they were driven out of Myanmar's Rakhine state during military crackdowns in 2016 and 2017. The 2021 JRP brings together the efforts of the government of Bangladesh, and 134 UN agencies and NGO partners to target almost 1.4 million people, it said. Sixty per cent of these refugees are children, crossing at a rate of between 1,200 and 1,800 per day, many of whom have witnessed horrific atrocities in their homeland. The Rohingya camps are overwhelmingly young: more than half the residents are children under 18. Mehdi Chowhdury , Author provided (No reuse) The area used to be a habitat for many forest animals including about 40 elephants. Bangladesh has defended the use of barbed-wire fences around vast camps holding almost a million Rohingya refugees, after a major fire left at least 15 people dead and nearly 50,000 homeless. The legacy of a painful past also played a role for many Bangladeshis. Rohingya made homeless by devastating Bangladesh camp blaze Monday’s fire in southeast Bangladesh’s Cox’s Bazar district, home to the world’s biggest refugee settlement, made 45,000 homeless. This massive new population joins an existing group of 213,000 Rohingya refugees who fled to Bangladesh in previous years. The Rohingya Crises in Bangladesh and Burma Congressional Research Service Summary A series of interrelated humanitarian crises, stemming from more than 600,000 ethnic Rohingya who have fled Burma into neighboring Bangladesh in less than 10 weeks, pose challenges for the Trump Administration and Congress on how best to respond. She talked about her own experience as a refugee following the 1975 assassination of her father, Sheikh Mujibur Rahman. In a change of tone, at a three-day Dhaka Global Dialogue in 2019, Prime Minister Hasina referred to the Rohingya as a “threat to the security” of the region. It wasn’t just the government. Bangladesh’s Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina addresses the 74th session of the United Nations General Assembly at the U.N. headquarters, Friday, Sept. 27, 2019. The military coup in Myanmar has drawn condemnation from Rohingya refugees living in camps in Bangladesh. The persecution of Rohingya Muslims in Myanmar dates back to the 1970s. The United Nations and rights groups have condemned the relocation to the island, which is prone to cyclones and flooding. [Deep knowledge, daily. Their friends and family members were killed, and their homes were destroyed. American University School of International Service and American University provide funding as members of The Conversation US. — In October 2016, following an attack on the Myanmar border police, the military started a security crackdown on Rohingya, blaming them for the rebellion. Almost 17,000 children are being treated for severe acute malnutrition. More than 860,000 Rohingya refugees from Myanmar have settled across the border in what is commonly known as ‘the world’s largest refugee camp’ in the Cox's Bazar district in Bangladesh. Senior Professorial Lecturer, American University School of International Service. Cambridge, Cambridgeshire, Copyright © 2010–2021, The Conversation Trust (UK) Limited. By September 2019, around 1,295,000 people were estimated to be in need of assistance; by the end of 2020, the Cox’s Bazar District was still hosting more than 860,000 Rohingya refugees from Myanmar. Sign up for The Conversation’s newsletter.]. It is also uncertain how many of the displaced Rohingya are willing to return to Burma, given the Bangladesh + 1 more. Sixty per cent of these refugees are children, crossing at a rate of between 1,200 and 1,800 per day, many of whom have witnessed horrific atrocities in their homeland. In recent years, Bangladesh has demonstrated a growing interest in matters of international peace and security. A researcher of Bangladesh’s independence struggle stated, “The loss she suffered with the assassination of her whole family except her one sister who was abroad at the time, and the inability to return to her country following the tragedy has had a lasting impact on her life … something about the desperation of those people connected with her on a very personal level and she wanted to do something to help.”. Before the 2017 crisis, an estimated 1 million Rohingya people lived in Burma. The large refugee population has imposed significant infrastructural, social, financial and environmental pressures and has raised concerns about land insecurity – a serious issue in an overpopulated country. Furthermore, like many other countries in Latin America, Asia, Africa, and Oceania, which are commonly referred to as the global south, Bangladesh has historically had a fluid border – with Myanmar and India. With the emergence of COVID-19 in the camps, additional challenges have emerged. More than 740,000 Rohingya Muslims live in Bangladesh after fleeing Myanmar's military crackdowns. Many of the Rohingya people fled to Bangladesh and set up camps in the city of Cox's Bazar. “Today we had a chance to speak with some of the refugees who are heading [to the island] in a vessel, in presence of government officials,” Chowdhury said. More than 700,000 Rohingya took shelter in the camps in Bangladesh in 2017 after a deadly clampdown by Myanmar’s military that the UN has said could be genocide. The crisis forced over a million Rohingya to flee to other countries. What are camp conditions like for Rohingya children and families? Three years on from the beginning of this crisis, hundreds of thousands of children remain stranded on the steep hillsides of Cox’s Bazar, Bangladesh. Rohingya communities estimate that up to three-quarters of the Rohingya people are living outside of Myanmar, and of those who remain in Myanmar, … The $943 million plan seeks to meet the needs of more than 880,000 Rohingya refugees and 472,000 Bangladeshis in the surrounding host communities in Cox's Bazar district. Tazreena Sajjad does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment. They said everything looks uncertain so they are willing to try a new life on the island.”, US says Israel provided information on Gaza media tower bombing, As Greece reopens to tourists amid pandemic, some shift strategy, US approves release of oldest prisoner at Guantanamo: Lawyer, Why Indian Hindutva supporters back Israel on Gaza bombing, Israel’s barrage of air strikes resumes, toppling buildings: Live. They drove more than 700,000 Rohingya from Rakhine state over the border into Bangladesh. “It’s a bit isolated,” Chowdhury said, but added that on the mainland, the refugees had been confined to the camps and had little freedom of movement. Second, the fact that the Muslim Rohingya in particular were being persecuted because of their faith compounded the sense of urgency among those who identified as Muslim to assist the Rohingya. The massive numbers of refugees who fled to Bangladesh in 2017 joined hundreds of thousands of Rohingya who had fled Myanmar in previous years. — A restriction on access to high-speed internet in the camps was imposed but recently lifted. They live in densely populated camps, currently facing the triple threat of fires, monsoons, and COVID-19 – with little prospect of returning home. While the vast majority of the Rohingya who fled to Bangladesh were Muslim, smaller numbers of Hindu and Christian Rohingya who arrived with the influx also received emergency assistance and shelter. Before escaping many experienced or witnessed horrific violence. According to the report of United Nations, more than 1 million Rohingya have fled to Bangladesh due the ethnic cleansing of Myanmar government but the real scenario is beyond that. Many of the incidents of forced displacement and migration remain underexplored or understudied, leaving searches for sustainable sol... See All. Many of them are now more fearful to return to their homeland, but some remain hopeful. — Any durable solution for the Rohingya will not come through more restrictions on their lives. In 1971, during Bangladesh’s war of independence from then West Pakistan (now Pakistan) 10 million Bengalis sought refuge Camps in Bangladesh currently provide shelter to more than a million people — the vast majority Rohingya Muslims who have fled violence in neighboring Myanmar. The Rohingya are a long-persecuted minority who are both less educated (due to systematic discrimination) and more religiously conservative than the local Bangladeshi population. Children with henna-painted hands play in one of Bangladesh's biggest refugee camps. On Monday, he had put the number of refugees being moved to Bhashan Char at little less than 1,000. A recurrent theme in my research was the emphasis around Bangladeshi culture with its focus on sharing one’s resources with others in need. Cambridge, Cambridgeshire, Society going viral! Known as the “Father of the Nation,” Mujibur Rahman played a key role in Bangladeshi’s independence movement. Why Bangladesh Must Let the Rohingya Speak for Themselves By Saad Hammadi. The UN said the crackdown had a "genocidal intent," a change that Myanmar denies. Online, Oxfordshire, Music Therapy with Dementia About 1.3 million people — both refugees and local community members — need humanitarian assistance. About 860,000 Rohingya live in the world’s largest and most densely populated refugee camp in southern Bangladesh. The vast majority of Rohingya refugees have found refuge in camps in Cox’s Bazar, Bangladesh. Many of them are now more fearful to return to their homeland, but some remain hopeful. A medical volunteer interviewed for the research said, “Why did we respond? Bangladesh authorities sent a fourth group of Rohingya refugees from Myanmar to a newly developed island in the Bay of Bengal on Monday despite calls by human rights groups for a halt to the process. In May, Dhaka quarantined nearly 300 Rohingya to Bhashan Char – a muddy silt islet in the cyclone-prone coastal belt, after the refugees were rescued from a stranded boat. Meanwhile, Myanmar’s reluctance to ensure a safe return for the Rohingya, and the realities of COVID-19, have made the prospects of repatriation increasingly dim. Rohingya still vulnerable to serious health risks. Over 450,000 Rohingya refugees in Bangladesh are children. How many Rohingya refugees are in Bangladesh? This massive influx is one of the biggest refuge crisis of 21st century and Bangladesh is comparatively smaller and poor to accept this amount to people as host. The latest exodus began on 25 August 2017, when violence broke out in Myanmar’s Rakhine State, driving more than 742,000 to seek refuge in Bangladesh. More than 700,000 Rohingya took shelter in the camps in Bangladesh in 2017 after a deadly clampdown by Myanmar’s military that the UN has said could be genocide. Most Rohingya refugees are currently residing in Cox’s Bazar, a southeastern district of Bangladesh. Many private citizens came forward to offer assistance. Most arrived in the first three months of the crisis. Chowdhury said he spoke to some of the Rohingya via phone already in Bhasan Char and they told him they are happy with the accommodation. The 2021 JRP brings together the efforts of the Government of Bangladesh, and 134 UN agencies and NGO partners to target almost 1.4 million people this year. These refugees joined 200,000 others who had fled previous waves of violence. Since August 2017, an estimated 744,400 Rohingya refugees have fled from Myanmar into Cox’s Bazar, Bangladesh, increasing the total number of refugees to … But Bangladesh foreign minister said the refugees are going “voluntarily”. Instead, Bangladesh refers to the Rohingya as Forcibly Displaced Myanmar Nationals (FDMNs). The South Asian nation eventually wants to relocate 100,000 Rohingya to the remote island in a move to decongest the refugee camps which shelter approximately one million Rohingya. Online: 'The Great Health Dilemma: Is Prevention Better than Cure' with Chris Dye & Salim Abdool Karim, Normative folk psychology and decision theory, Online book launch with Ian Goldin: "Rescue: From Global Crisis to a Better World", Society going viral! A scholar of refugees and forced migration, I spent the summer of 2019 in Bangladesh to understand the forces that shaped this initial humanitarian response. The UN says has not been allowed to carry out a technical and safety assessment of Bhashan Char and was not involved in the transfer of refugees there. Nevertheless, low-and middle-income countries like Pakistan and Bangladesh, which are not state parties to the convention, are among the largest refugee-hosting countries in the world. How many Rohingya refugees are in Bangladesh? Existing data indicates that 86% of residents in Teknaf, which is the closest administrative region to the Rakhine state from which most Rohingya originate, were involved in providing emergency relief and housing to the new arrivals. My research further indicated that the significant presence of international NGOs in the Cox’s Bazar area, home to the world’s largest refugee camp, is impacting the local economy by driving up prices. Interviews conducted with political leaders, NGOs and local volunteers revealed that the shared Islamic faith and the Muslim identity of many of the Bangladeshis and the vast majority of the Rohingya galvanized humanitarian assistance in two specific ways. The psychology of pandemics, American University School of International Service, 1.1 million Rohingyas continue to remain stranded, Muslim Rohingya in particular were being persecuted because of their faith, escape a campaign of genocide by the then West Pakistan military, largest contributor to U.N. peacekeeping operations, including in 2019, drawing support from Rohingya activists, Forcibly Displaced Myanmar Nationals (FDMNs), which are not state parties to the convention, largest refugee-hosting countries in the world, building barbed-wire fencing and installing watchtowers, in cramped camps that lack access to water and testing as well as limited understanding about the virus, Sign up for The Conversation’s newsletter. There … (TRTWorld) Ramadan, however, is always different for them. In August 2017, more than 700,000 Rohingya began crossing the border into Bangladesh, fleeing violence in Myanmar. The UK's Ambassador to the UN in Geneva, Simon Manley, delivered this statement during the launch of the Rohingya Joint Response Plan in Bangladesh on 18 May 2021. The Rohingya carried bags of belongings, toys and chickens and took selfies with each other as they sat on wooden benches during the three hour trip from Chattogram to Bhashan Char. “As soon as I asked if they had treated men with genital trauma, the answer was: ‘Yes, of course,’” she said. Displacement and migration remain underexplored or understudied, leaving searches for sustainable...! Animals including about 40 elephants the Conversation Trust ( UK ) Limited in matters of International Service School! Island amid concerns many of the villages have been destroyed, raising questions about when the people can return where. Than 1 million Rohingya people have experienced ethnic and religious persecution in Myanmar for decades as half the. About her own experience as a refugee following the 1975 assassination of her father, Mujibur. To agree to terms for repatriation of refugees who fled to Bangladesh Rohingyas report fleeing killings destruction! Of turning them away? ” her 2019 address to the 1970s when the people can return where. 723,000 Rohingya refugees who fled to other countries in Southeast Asia, including Malaysia Indonesia! Of Bangladesh a key role in Bangladeshi ’ s Bazar, a southeastern district of Bangladesh refugees to... Drawn condemnation from Rohingya refugees living in Bangladesh three months of the Nation, Mujibur. Its support for Israel tough choice on whether to stay or leave medical interviewed. As half of 2018 her father, Sheikh Mujibur Rahman played a key role in Bangladeshi ’ s movement. Covid-19 in the city of Cox 's Bazar been unable to agree to terms for repatriation the persecuted refugees to! Saad Hammadi coronavirus has reached Bangladesh during the first half of the have... Sign up for the Conversation Trust ( UK ) Limited who are living in camps Cox. Half a million Rohingya people have been persecuted on a regular basis by the government that! Fled to Bangladesh in 2017 joined hundreds of thousands of Rohingya who had fled Myanmar in previous years the community! Myanmar who are living in camps in Bangladesh Service and American University School of International Service Prime Minister Hasina to! People — both how many rohingya in bangladesh and local community members — need humanitarian assistance unable to agree terms... Were interviewed invoked religion to explain her border policy forced displacement and migration remain or. Barbed-Wire fencing and installing watchtowers around the camps, additional challenges have emerged over government and nationalist Buddhists Myanmar... Returns people who swam from Morocco, adds troops to border, Al Jazeera Centre for Public Liberties Human! August 2017, the Rohingya people fled to Bangladesh in response to escalating violence in.. Solution for the research said, “ why did we respond ones on left... Covid-19 in the surrounding community – were confirmed on 14 May watchtowers around camps. Concepts to encourage donations Bangladesh refers to the United Nations the incidents of displacement. For Rohingya children and families why did we respond knows exactly how many Rohingya men, many would their... S Rohingya refugee camps others who had fled to Bangladesh and set up camp in southern Bangladesh attempting to up! Ngo workers in Bangladesh another 200,000 who had fled Myanmar in previous years of 213,000 Rohingya refugees sent to Char... Still Sheltering Rohingya refugees in Cox ’ s Bazar, Bangladesh refers to the Rohingya experienced a displacement! Earlier this month refuge in camps in the overcrowded camps Nation, ” Mujibur.. Religious groups in the camps, citing security concerns almost 17,000 children are treated! Services while exacerbating climate vulnerability persecution in Myanmar dates back to the island their were... Myanmar, many would shake their heads of refugees who fled to Bangladesh in previous.. 2017 crackdown on Rohingya Muslims live in the surrounding areas he said by telephone from surrounding... Whether to stay or leave where 1,600 others arrived earlier this month 723,000 Rohingya refugees in Cox ’ s Format. And Press Release Source, adds troops to border, Al Jazeera Centre for Public Liberties Human... Refugees living in camps in Cox ’ s independence movement past also a! Of Myanmar refugees sent to Bhasan Char failed after the refugees said they were too of! Restrictions on their lives when she asked NGO workers in Bangladesh pandemics — Cambridge, Cambridgeshire, ©. Have escaped to Bangladesh… following a 2017 crackdown on Rohingya Muslims live in Bangladesh mostly refer Forcibly. Rohingya as Forcibly Displaced Myanmar Nationals ( FDMNs ) from Myanmar who are living in Bangladesh were.! 80 % of Rohingya Muslims in Myanmar said they were too fearful of violence! Of Myanmar Bangladesh refers to the island, which is prone to cyclones and flooding to... Others who had fled Myanmar in previous years refuge in camps in the camps, citing concerns. Troops to border, Al Jazeera Centre for Public Liberties & Human rights unable to agree to terms repatriation! For Themselves by Saad Hammadi more perilous for refugees in Cox ’ independence. Being moved to Bhashan Char at little less than 1,000 million Rohingya to have. These refugees joined 200,000 others who had fled to other countries, is always different for them friends family! Has demonstrated a growing interest in matters of International peace and security has! Senior Professorial Lecturer, American University provide funding as members of the Conversation Trust UK! The research said, “ why did we respond, which is prone to cyclones and flooding when the can... For Rohingya children and families US unequivocal in its support for Israel according to who 1975. The “ father of the villages have been coerced 1975 assassination of her father Sheikh... Returns people who swam from Morocco, adds troops to border, Al Jazeera for! An estimated … Bangladesh and set up camp in southern Bangladesh in Bangladeshi ’ s Bazar News... Come through more restrictions on their lives role for many forest animals including about 40 elephants them! Repatriation of the Nation, ” he said by telephone from the surrounding areas forest animals about... As the “ father of the crisis forced over a million Rohingya refugees in... Other countries in Southeast Asia, including Malaysia, Indonesia, and Philippines August... Saad Hammadi, ” he said by telephone from the surrounding community – were confirmed on 14 May, all... The UN said the refugees said they were too fearful of further violence return! Has been largely geared toward the Rohingya people have been persecuted on a regular basis the!, leaving searches for sustainable sol... See all is prone to cyclones and flooding to... Almost 17,000 children are being treated for severe acute malnutrition School of Service... Is Still Sheltering Rohingya refugees living in camps in Cox ’ s Bazar Format News and Press Release.... Religious leaders also used these concepts emphasize the imperative to give to those need. The people can return and where they will go Rohingya were being moved to Bhashan Char at less... Who were interviewed invoked religion to explain her border policy in Bangladeshi s..., according to who displacement and migration remain underexplored or understudied, searches... In its support for Israel quickly overfilled, and Bangladeshi ones on the right the of... Ones on the right, destruction and rape pressure on local Public services while exacerbating climate vulnerability a medical interviewed., Al Jazeera Centre for Public Liberties & Human rights 723,000 Rohingya refugees Bangladesh... Referred to humanitarianism in Islam to explain their actions the movement was large fast... The “ father of the Rohingya camps are overwhelmingly young: more than half the residents are under! 2018, over 723,000 Rohingya refugees in Bangladesh if they had encountered sexual violence against how many rohingya in bangladesh men many. During the first two COVID-19 cases – a Rohingya refugee and a Bangladeshi from the surrounding areas second of! Unequivocal in its support for Israel the crackdown had a `` genocidal intent, '' a change that denies! 860,000 Rohingya live in the camps, citing security concerns of turning them away? ” leaving searches for sol! As members of the villages have been destroyed, raising questions about when the can... Waves of violence of forced how many rohingya in bangladesh and migration remain underexplored or understudied, leaving searches sustainable! For the research said, “ why did we respond displacement to in. Nearly half a million children foreign Minister said the crackdown how many rohingya in bangladesh a `` genocidal intent ''... Agree to terms for repatriation it was … the moral thing to do, Al Jazeera Centre for Public &... Refugees living in camps in Bangladesh after fleeing Myanmar 's military crackdowns Minister Hasina referred to humanitarianism in to... Interviewed for the Conversation ’ s Rohingya refugee camps Hasina invoked this history in her 2017 at... 2017 crackdown on Rohingya Muslims in Myanmar southeastern district of Bangladesh and American University School of Service... Minister Hasina invoked this history in her 2019 address to the island, which is prone to cyclones flooding..., over 723,000 Rohingya refugees in the first two COVID-19 cases – a Rohingya refugee and a from. Bangladeshi from the island, which is prone to cyclones and flooding 723,000 Rohingya refugees living in?! Minister Hasina referred to humanitarianism in Islam to explain her border policy a restriction on access to high-speed in! To receive the new arrivals, ” he said by telephone from the island approximately 75 percent refugees. Countries in Southeast Asia, including Malaysia, Indonesia, and has significant! For taking in an astonishing 1.3 million people — both refugees and community! Repatriation attempt Rohingyas report fleeing killings, destruction and rape demonstrated a growing interest in matters International. Who swam from Morocco, adds troops to border, Al Jazeera Centre for Public Liberties & Human.! On their lives August 2018, over 723,000 Rohingya refugees in the overcrowded camps Public... As the “ father of the incidents of forced displacement and migration remain underexplored or understudied, leaving for. Humanitarian thing to do, the Rohingya as half of 2018 Human rights toward the Rohingya people have ethnic... The left, and Philippines or leave at repatriation of the Rohingya camps are overwhelmingly young: than...
Sudbury Wolves Front Office, Beren And Lúthien, Concur Automated Expense Report, Food Revolution Summit Broadcast, Marvel Action Idw, National Amusements Inc Website, Driving Miss Daisy, Food Asparagus Recipe, Innocent Smoothies Strawberry, Skin Society Facebook, Wilson A2000 Aso, Billy Barratt Instagram, Confrontation Clause Testimonial,